
Planned Maintenance vs Reactive Repair: Comparing Kitchen Costs
Planned preventative maintenance (PPM) and reactive repair serve different purposes. A service programme can help identify developing problems and organise maintenance, while unexpected faults may still need a repair visit. The decision is not simply “contract or no contract”.
Whether a particular proposal offers better value depends on the assets, operating demands, maintenance requirements, contract exclusions and actual fault history. There is no guaranteed percentage saving or universal lifespan extension.
What are you comparing?
PPM is an agreed schedule of work on specified equipment. Reactive repair addresses reported faults. A PPM agreement may or may not include breakdown labour, travel, parts, inspection work or particular response arrangements. Compare the written scope rather than assuming these are bundled together.
HSE's maintenance guidance for catering distinguishes cleaning, routine checks, planned maintenance, breakdown maintenance, and inspections and tests. A financial comparison must not become a reason to omit maintenance needed for safe operation.
Use your own records to build the cost comparison
- Planned work: the quoted visits, equipment covered, tasks and exclusions.
- Additional repairs: actual or forecast parts, labour and visits outside the contract.
- Operational disruption: recorded lost capacity, temporary arrangements and other relevant costs.
- Administration: time spent reporting faults, arranging access and checking documentation.
- Condition and replacement: age, recurring faults, parts availability and planned equipment changes.
Use comparable time periods and avoid counting the same cost twice. Lost sales are not automatically the same as lost profit: use an appropriate contribution or other agreed business measure when estimating financial impact.
A worked comparison without invented prices
Start with two totals for the same asset list and period:
- Reactive approach: required routine upkeep + repair invoices + measured disruption + relevant administration.
- Proposed PPM: contract fee + work excluded from that contract + forecast disruption + relevant administration.
Populate the first total from records. For the second, use the quotation and make assumptions about future faults explicit. Compare more than one scenario rather than assuming all breakdowns disappear. Our maintenance contract finance guide discusses the financial assessment in more detail.
Which assets deserve particular attention?
Consider how heavily each appliance is used, whether there is a practical alternative during a fault and what the manufacturer recommends. A heavily used warewasher with repeated interruptions may justify a different maintenance discussion from lightly used equipment with a different history.
That is an illustrative decision pattern, not a completed client case or proof that one plan always costs less. Safety duties and competent assessment apply in both cases.
Questions to ask about a PPM proposal
- Which appliances, tasks and visit frequencies are included?
- How were the intervals chosen for the equipment and use?
- Are parts, consumables, descaling, breakdown labour and travel included?
- Which inspections or tests are separate, and how are due dates tracked?
- How are faults reported, assessed and scheduled between planned visits?
- What reports are provided, and who owns outstanding actions?
- How are changes, exclusions and cancellation terms documented?
Coordinating more than one site
A shared equipment schedule and consistent records can help coordinate work across locations. Check the scope and arrangements for each site; do not assume a national contract brings a fixed discount, guaranteed attendance or an included software dashboard.
Discuss a maintenance plan based on your operation
Gather the asset list, manufacturer guidance, recent service and repair records, operating hours and recurring problems. Read about planned commercial kitchen maintenance and reactive catering support, or ask HK Engineering to discuss the available options.







